Yeonpyeong-Cheonan comparisons

by Malcolm Cook - 30 November 2010 10:42AM

At first glance, the action-reaction scripts for the DPRK's two recent acts of war against South Korea seem depressingly similar:

  1. The North attacks the South.
  2. There is an immediate global call for calm, no escalation (largely ignoring the fact that a non-military response to North Korea is itself an escalation) and, bizarrely, even to reward Pyongyang for its violence.
  3. China refuses to condemn its only ally, while Chinese voices help the DPRK muddy the waters by claiming that the DPRK is somehow the victim and was goaded into reaction.

Looking a little closer, though, there seem to be four positive differences:

  1. Unlike the Cheonan attack, the Yeonpyeong attack (the first military attack on South Korean land by the North since 1953) has rallied the South Korean population against the North.
  2. Russia has publicly condemned North Korea.
  3. The Australian Government and Foreign Minister Rudd seem to have strengthened their already strong language against the DPRK and on China's need to bring more pressure on Pyongyang.
  4. The US and South Korea carried out naval drills in the Yellow Sea (with an Australian observer on board) despite DPRK and Chinese opposition.
Australia in the Asian Century

An Interpreter feature examining the themes of the Gillard Government’s ‘Australia in the Asian Century’ White Paper. Click here to see every post published in this series.

Email Digest  

To receive a weekly digest of ‘Australia in the Asian Century’ posts from The Interpreter via email, enter your email address:

Receive a weekly digest ->

Preview   |   Powered by FeedBlitz

Selected Interpreter posts also appear in:

 
Business Spectator Caing online The Diplomat
 

Keep up-to-date with The Interpreter through:

iPhone App   iPhone App

RSS Feed   The Interpreter RSS Feed

Email Digest  

To receive a digest of posts from The Interpreter via email, enter your email address:

Receive a daily digest ->
Receive a weekly digest ->

Preview   |   Powered by FeedBlitz

Interpreting the Aid Review

This is the archive of a Lowy Institute blog which ran from January to April of 2011. It was published to debate the Gillard Government's independent aid review, which was then in its research and consultation phase. We offer this archive as a service to researchers and the general public.